An error occurred while saving the commentJulien Chichignoud commented
@Kevin Monahan. This isn't the issue. With the LUTs correctly installed, they still get selected based on position in the list.
I wrote this on the issue last year: https://julien.chichignoud.com/how-to-avoid-lut-headaches-in-premiere
TL;DR: The only workaround is to name your added LUTs in a way that make them show up at the bottom of the list (I preprend "zz_" to the name, personally).