Kyle Hamrick
My feedback
-
5 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
2 votesKyle Hamrick
shared this idea
·
-
76 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
184 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
23 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
64 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
21 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
27 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
29 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
2 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
8 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
8 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment Kyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
82 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
329 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
11 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
8 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
2 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
359 votes
An error occurred while saving the comment Kyle Hamrick
commented
The behavior definitely sounds useful, and any time we can achieve consistency with other Adobe apps is always nice.
I use alt-dragging (to "accordion" keys) relatively frequently (and also use ctrl+alt+click to toggle Hold fairly frequently), but I feel like I might agree with Steve that Ctrl+Alt+Click might be negotiable. That said, this probably means I'm suggesting changing TWO existing behaviors (alt+drag becomes Duplicate, ctrl+alt+drag becomes "accordion"), which sounds insane.
As I was typing this, I wonder if I've perhaps stumbled onto something - maybe I'm crazy, but would it be possible to hold the D key (for, you know, *D*uplicate) to accomplish this? While the key is different, the behavior is in line with other Adobe apps. As AE is already such a complex program, users are used to getting similar behaviors, but with different hotkeys... (It's probably not possible to separate this from the existing functionality of D to "Scroll to current time," is it? Would this be an easier change to swallow?)
+1 for this needing to work for keys on multiple layers at once.
+1 for being able to add another modifier key to reverse the copied keys.
+1 for being able to force the keys to sit on exact frames.
+1 for a bounding box that allows you to both see what you're doing and intuitively manipulate the group of keys (similar to behavior within the Graph Editor).
-
5 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
-
2 votesKyle Hamrick
supported this idea
·
Completely agree. Having it off by default feels like a holdover from days of slower systems, and I would happily manually deal with the 2% of times when I don't need this, vs having to remember to enable it for the other 98%.